Last updated October 6, 2026 · ranked from 606 Google reviews · How we rank
This list ranks 10 real estate agents in and around Lake Orion, MI, led by Susan Garbarino, Realtor, Estate Sale Specialist / Liberty Way Realty, James Gillen III, Liberty Way Realty and Zack Schewe Realtor | Liberty Way Realty Lake Orion. Together they have 606 Google reviews; Susan Garbarino, Realtor, Estate Sale Specialist / Liberty Way Realty has the highest Google rating on the list at 5.0. Every place on the list is in Lake Orion, MI. Rankings weigh Google rating, review volume, how complete and current each listing is, and our own notes on each place.
Consistent communication and hands-on transaction support put Susan Garbarino of Liberty Way Realty at No. 1 in Lake Orion, MI. Her 5-star Google rating across 91 reviews is backed by accounts of responsive updates during a property sale, willingness to make tough requests in negotiations, and flexibility around a buyer’s schedule. One reviewer describes purchasing a first home using VA mortgage eligibility. Based at 400 S Broadway St, Garbarino assists with residential and commercial buying, selling, and leasing, with online appointments and onsite services available.
Responsive client communication
Residential and commercial
Flexible appointment options
“Miss Susan was an absolutely wonderful realtor to work with! I am a veteran and we chose to use my VA mortgage eligibility to purchase our family's first home! Through out the entire process she was such a joy to work with! She was able …”
Work at Susan Garbarino, Realtor, Estate Sale Specialist / Liberty Way Realty? Get your badge
Clear communication and help with complicated purchases earn James Gillen III, Liberty Way Realty the No. 2 spot in Lake Orion, MI. His 5-star Google rating across 74 reviews is supported by accounts of keeping buyers and sellers informed at each step. One client describes his professional guidance through a tricky inspection in a competitive neighborhood; another credits his flexibility with weekend showings and handling tasks for buyers living two hours away. His office is at 400 S Broadway St.
5-star Google rating
Inspection guidance
Flexible weekend showings
“Liberty Way Realty is the best! Over 2 years ago they helped us buy our home and they just sold our old house after it was totally renovated inside due to pipe bursting. Listed and sold within a week!”
Work at James Gillen III, Liberty Way Realty? Get your badge
Clear communication and guidance for first-time buyers earn Zack Schewe of Liberty Way Realty the No. 3 spot in Lake Orion, MI. Reviewers describe prompt answers, punctuality, a non-pushy approach, and help from start to finish. Several specifically credit him with making their first home purchase easier. His Google listing holds a 5-star rating across 72 reviews. A lifelong Michigan resident with years of nonprofit work, Schewe offers online appointments and onsite services at 400 S Broadway St.
First-time buyer guidance
Prompt communication
Online appointments
“Zach is the man! We recently closed a deal together and I have no complaints. His communication was great the whole way through. Thanks for making it a smooth transaction. Hope your clients enjoy their new home!”
Work at Zack Schewe Realtor | Liberty Way Realty Lake Orion? Get your badge
Patient house hunting and quick responses help explain Peg Dilworth-Hunt’s No. 4 ranking in Lake Orion, MI. Reviewers describe looking at many homes without feeling rushed, finding a home within budget, and receiving professional support through both selling and buying. Based at Coldwell Banker Professionals on N Park Blvd, she has worked in real estate since 2014. Her services include pricing strategy, marketing plans, and local market guidance. A 5-star Google rating from 47 reviews adds support to that record of attentive service.
Patient buyer guidance
Responsive communication
Strategic pricing plans
“Terrific experience! 10 out of 10. Peg Hunt is an amazing realtor, and went above and beyond to help us with the sale of our home in Clarkston! We didn’t need to make many changes to our home to get it ready for sale, any suggestions she…”
Patient home searches and clear explanations help earn The Integrity Team at Keller Williams Collaborative its No. 5 spot in Lake Orion, MI. Reviewers describe responsive agents, an unrushed first-home purchase, and steady communication through both buying and selling. The team reports more than 40 years of real estate experience and over 2,700 homes sold, with guidance covering pricing, preparation, inspections, negotiations, and closing. Its 4.9-star Google rating across 84 reviews adds support, while online appointments and onsite services offer two ways to meet.
Patient buyer guidance
Clear seller communication
Online appointments available
“Laura Cattermole is an amazing realtor! She was incredibly patient and took the time to show us numerous homes throughout the Rochester area until we found our new home. She is very professional, knowledgeable, responsive, and truly care…”
Work at The Integrity Team at Keller Williams Collaborative? Get your badge
Firsthand waterfront knowledge helps Kristin Berry - Epique Realty earn the No. 6 spot. A lifelong resident of Lake Orion, MI and a waterfront homeowner, Berry has been licensed since 2015 and specializes in waterfront, luxury and residential properties. Her background in finance, marketing and interior design informs her work with buyers and sellers, while her local network creates off-market opportunities. Reviewers praise clear communication, quick responses and patient, pressure-free guidance. The practice holds a 5-star Google rating from 28 reviews.
Waterfront property knowledge
Licensed since 2015
Patient buyer guidance
“Well what can I say about Kristin Berry and Epique Realty, besides exceptionally exceptional !!! Kristin is amazing. Her communication was top notch. I used her as a Buyers Agent, The house we found, while needing some love, felt li…”
Support through both buying and selling earns The Brokaw Group & Brokaw Commercial Real Estate rank 7 among real estate agents serving Lake Orion, MI. Reviewers describe guidance for a first-time buyer, responsive communication, and help coordinating a home sale with a new purchase. One client reports using the group to sell several properties. Its 5-star Google rating across 27 reviews complements more than a decade serving Michigan, with stated specialties spanning residential and commercial properties, waterfront homes, probate, and downsizing.
First-time buyer guidance
Residential and commercial
Responsive communication
“Being a first time home buyer I had no clue where to even begin but Josh from Brokaw Group guided me through the entire process making this home buying experience enjoyable and easy. Josh helped every step of the way and till this day (5…”
Work at The Brokaw Group & Brokaw Commercial Real Estate? Get your badge
Patience and consistent communication earn Dawn Hendrix - Realtor the No. 8 spot in Lake Orion, MI. Her Google listing carries a 5-star rating from 35 reviews, with clients describing guidance through both buying and selling. One first-time buyer credits her with reducing stress from preapproval through closing; another reviewer notes her understanding during the emotional sale of a parent’s house. A buyer also praises her patience while they searched for the right place, giving specific examples of support beyond the transaction paperwork.
Patient buyer guidance
Consistent client communication
First-time buyer support
“Was patient with me while I took my time finding the just right place !”
Communication and dependability help earn Brandi Ingram Realtor | Liberty Way Realty Oakland County the No. 9 spot in Lake Orion, MI. Based at 400 S Broadway St, Ingram works with buyers and sellers, including those relocating or investing. The business holds a 5-star Google rating from 27 reviews. One reviewer describes her as professional and knowledgeable, with attention to securing a good deal for clients; another praises her efforts to ensure clear communication and understanding. Her stated approach also emphasizes organization and informed decisions.
Buyer and seller support
5-star Google rating
Communication praised
“I have known Brandi for nearly a decade now and she has always been a delight!
She is one of the most helpful and dependable people I have ever worked with or known. She goes to great lengths to ensure communication and understanding, s…”
Work at Brandi Ingram Realtor | Liberty Way Realty Oakland County? Get your badge
Seller feedback helps put Liberty Way Realty at No. 10: reviewers describe being kept informed throughout a sale, prompt help with listing a home, and a quick, efficient sale. The family-owned company has operated since 2011 and serves residential and commercial buyers and sellers across Southeast Michigan. Based at 400 S Broadway St in Lake Orion, MI, it holds a 4.8 Google rating from 121 reviews. Online appointments and on-site services give clients two ways to connect with the team.
Clear seller communication
Online appointments available
Residential and commercial
“I joined Liberty Way from a different brokerage last year and haven't looked back since. The support staff here is great and all the other agents here are awesome as well! Love the fact that it's locally owned and operated too.”
Ratings and review counts shown are Google ratings, displayed with attribution.
How we ranked this list
Each real estate agent is scored on a Bayesian-weighted rating (its rating adjusted for how many reviews it has compared with the Lake Orion category average), how recently we verified its details, and how complete its listing is. Scores and ranks are stored, so the order only changes when the underlying data changes.
Real Estate Agents in Lake Orion, MI: common questions
Which agents in Lake Orion, MI have the most Google reviews?
Liberty Way Realty leads this guide with 121 reviews and a 4.8 rating. Susan Garbarino follows with 91 reviews and a 5.0 rating, while The Integrity Team at Keller Williams Collaborative has 84 reviews and a 4.9 rating. James Gillen III and Zack Schewe each have 5.0 ratings, from 74 and 72 reviews respectively.
Who specializes in waterfront properties in Lake Orion, MI?
Kristin Berry specializes in waterfront, luxury and residential real estate in Lake Orion, MI and northern Oakland County. She is a lifelong resident and waterfront homeowner, with an office at 129 S Broadway St. The Brokaw Group & Brokaw Commercial Real Estate also lists waterfront properties among its specialties, alongside condominiums, new construction and large parcels.
Which agents have experience helping first-time buyers?
The Integrity Team explicitly serves first-time buyers, and a review describes working with Dave Rayner without feeling rushed. Zack Schewe has several reviews from first-time buyers praising his guidance. A Dawn Hendrix review describes support from preapproval through closing, while a Susan Garbarino review recounts a veteran's first-home purchase using VA mortgage eligibility.
Which agents in Lake Orion, MI list evening or weekend hours?
Peg Dilworth-Hunt lists 8 a.m.–8 p.m. Monday through Saturday and 9 a.m.–8 p.m. Sunday. Sue Campbell lists hours until 11 p.m. Monday through Thursday, 11:30 p.m. Friday, 6 p.m. Saturday and 7 p.m. Sunday. Susan Garbarino, Zack Schewe, Dawn Hendrix, Kristin Berry and Brandi Ingram each list 24-hour availability daily.
Who handles commercial real estate or leasing around Lake Orion, MI?
Susan Garbarino provides residential and commercial assistance for buying, selling and leasing from 400 S Broadway St, Lake Orion, MI. Liberty Way Realty also handles residential and commercial buying and selling. The Brokaw Group & Brokaw Commercial Real Estate, at 334 S Broadway St, Orion Township, MI, lists commercial and multi-family properties among its specialties.
1
