The 10 Best Insurance Agencies in Lake Orion, MI

Scott Ockerman - State Farm Insurance Agent

Insurance agency

Responsive help and quick problem-solving support Scott Ockerman - State Farm Insurance Agent’s No. 1 ranking in Lake Orion, MI. The agency holds a 4.9 Google rating from 187 reviews, with reviewers praising helpful service and prompt attention to issues. One customer describes getting new home, vehicle, and boat coverage while saving more than $200 a month. Located at 403 S Broadway St, the office opens Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. and provides a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking.

• 4.9 Google rating
• Quick problem-solving
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance

“Always fantastic, top notch service, from Scott Okerman state farm branch. Jeff,Blaine and Renne are fantastic people!”

FAMILY SHIELD INSURANCE GROUP

Insurance agency

Clear explanations and quick responses recur in reviews of FAMILY SHIELD INSURANCE GROUP, supporting its No. 2 rank alongside a 5-star Google rating from 65 reviews. This independent agency at 1290 S Lapeer Rd in Lake Orion, MI works with multiple carriers to tailor coverage to individual needs. Reviewers describe help with home, investment-property and auto insurance, including lower prices and, in one account, better coverage. The office is open weekdays from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking.

• Multiple insurance carriers
• Responsive policy guidance
• Wheelchair-accessible office

“Leo helped me get home insurance for my personal home and an investment property. Not only did he beat other prices I received but also with better coverage. His quick response time made the process smooth and straightforward. Highly rec…”

Jamie Felix - State Farm Insurance Agent

Insurance agency

Honest answers and responsive help underpin Jamie Felix - State Farm Insurance Agent’s No. 3 ranking in Lake Orion, MI. The agency holds a 4.8 Google rating from 70 reviews, with reviewers describing patient account setup, resolved insurance issues and thoughtful support for both for-profit and nonprofit work. One customer reports getting more coverage at a better price. Located at 95 Indianwood Rd, the office opens Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. and has a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking.

• Honest answers
• Patient account setup
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance

“Great customer service! Answers all questions honestly.”

Don Sherman - State Farm Insurance Agent

Insurance agency

Reviewers’ accounts of quick responses, thorough explanations, and help finding rates suited to their needs earn Don Sherman - State Farm Insurance Agent the No. 4 spot. The agency at 32 N Broadway St in Lake Orion, MI holds a 4.7-star Google rating across 97 reviews. Several reviewers specifically praise Marc for answering questions and completing requests promptly. Appointments are required, with online appointments and onsite services available. The office also lists wheelchair-accessible parking, an entrance, a restroom, and seating.

• Quick responses
• Online appointments available
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance

“Marc is very knowledgeable, thorough, and worked with me to get the best rates possible for my needs!”

Great Lakes Independent Insurance Agency, Inc.

Insurance agency

Help with complicated coverage changes earns Great Lakes Independent Insurance Agency, Inc. the No. 5 spot. Reviewers describe patient explanations, an easier insurer switch after an interstate move, and help arranging home insurance for a property in an estate. The agency holds a 4.7-star Google rating from 201 reviews. At 36 W Flint St in Lake Orion, MI, it lists auto, home, life, business, and specialty coverage, with carrier comparisons and personalized insurance reviews. Its office is open weekdays from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.

• Personalized coverage reviews
• Personal and business coverage
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance

“My agent Danielle was AMAZING! She was so helpful and patient and explained everything so nicely.”

Haney Farm Bureau

Insurance agency

Listening to clients’ needs is a recurring theme in reviews of Haney Farm Bureau, earning it the No. 6 spot. Reviewers describe Wayne Haney and his team as taking time to understand goals and explain insurance, with one praising coverage and premiums. The agency holds a 4.7-star Google rating from 31 reviews. Located at 344 S Broadway St in Lake Orion, MI, it offers online appointments and onsite services, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking. Office hours are Monday through Friday, 9 a.m.–5 p.m.

• Online appointments
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance
• 4.7-star Google rating

“Wayne and his staff has been great . Thanks for everything buddy”

Steven Hoffman - HUB International

Insurance agency

A single contact for multiple insurance needs helps Steven Hoffman - HUB International earn rank 7 in Lake Orion, MI. Hoffman describes himself as a licensed, multi-line agent who can manage a client’s entire insurance program. Reviewers with home and auto policies praise his helpfulness, knowledge, and quick responses. The agency holds a 5-star Google rating from six reviews. Its office at 18 S Broadway St has a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking, with weekday hours from 9 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.

• Multi-line insurance agent
• Reviewers praise responsiveness
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance

“I've been with Steven for both my home and car insurance, and I couldn’t be happier with the service I’ve received! He is always friendly, helpful, and responsive whenever I have a question or need assistance. He made the whole process s…”

Gerry Farm Bureau Agency

Insurance agency

Help with both new policies and renewals earns Gerry Farm Bureau Agency its No. 8 spot. One reviewer describes Matthew working after dinner and early in the morning to handle year-end policy changes; others praise his professionalism, courtesy, and attention to appropriate coverage and cost. The agency at 18 S Broadway St in Lake Orion, MI has a 5-star Google rating from four reviews. Its stated approach centers on understanding customers’ needs before creating a customized plan, with Saturday morning hours available.

• Policy renewal help
• Saturday morning hours
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance

“Always a pleasure working with Matthew, very professional and courteous.”

Sweet Insurance Agency - Lake Orion

Insurance agency · Orion Township · 0.4 mi

A family-owned history dating to 1919 and five listed coverage categories earn Sweet Insurance Agency its No. 9 spot among insurance agencies in Lake Orion, MI. Its offerings span commercial, home, auto, health, and life insurance. One longtime customer praises the team’s service and expresses trust that it keeps their interests in mind. The Google listing has a 5-star rating from two reviews. The office at 109 Indianwood Rd opens weekdays from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. and has a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking.

• Family-owned since 1919
• Five coverage categories
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance

“I want to take a moment of a crazy day as usual and thank the FANTASTIC team, Tom Powrie and group at the outstanding service that they do. I have been a customer for years and refuse to shop because I know they have my best interest and…”

Kathleen Novetsky LLC - Insurance Specialist for Haney Farm Bureau Insurance

Insurance agency

Personal, commercial, and life insurance offerings earn Kathleen Novetsky LLC - Insurance Specialist for Haney Farm Bureau Insurance the No. 10 spot. Located at 344 S Broadway St in Lake Orion, MI, the agency offers online appointments and on-site services, with weekday hours from 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. Free on-site parking and wheelchair-accessible parking add practical convenience. The women-owned business also identifies as LGBTQ-welcoming and a transgender safe space. Its Google listing has a 5-star rating from one review.

• Online appointments
• Three coverage categories
• Free on-site parking