Last updated October 23, 2026 · ranked from 1,349 Google reviews · How we rank
This list ranks 5 ice cream shops in and around Lake Orion, MI, led by 20 Front Street, Eva’s Dairy Cafe and Nutz About Chocolate. Together they have 1,349 Google reviews; 20 Front Street has the highest Google rating on the list at 4.9. Every place on the list is in Lake Orion, MI. Rankings weigh Google rating, review volume, how complete and current each listing is, and our own notes on each place.
20 Front Street holds a 4.9 Google rating across 470 reviews, listed on Google as ice cream.
“This venue offers such a unique and memorable experience. The intimate setting, warm wooden tones, and cozy atmosphere create the perfect backdrop for enjoying talented solo artists and small acoustic groups in a way that feels personal …”
Eva’s Dairy Cafe holds a 4.6 Google rating across 610 reviews, listed on Google as ice cream.
Old-fashioned strawberry soda
Open until 10
Cash only
“One of the few places you can get a traditional Old Fashioned Strawberry Soda. Got my husband hooked. They make them perfectly!! Try one, you won't regret it.”
Daily scratch-baked cookies give Cookies & Cream a second draw alongside its ice cream at 20 Front St in Lake Orion, MI. Its fourth-place spot reflects a 4.4 Google rating from 137 reviews, with customers praising the ice cream and friendly service. Reviewers mention Michigan pothole, black cherry and SuperCow among their choices. Seating, free public parking and a location next to Children’s Park make it practical for a family stop, though some reviewers criticize the prices and portion sizes.
Daily scratch-baked cookies
Next to Children’s Park
Free public parking
“The ice cream was delicious, and the service was amazing.”
Late closing hours and a broad selection of frozen treats help Baskin-Robbins earn the fifth spot. At 378 S Broadway St in Lake Orion, MI, the shop offers ice cream in many flavors, sundaes, and cakes, with dine-in, takeout, pickup, and delivery options. Its Google rating is 4.3 out of 5 from 48 reviews, including praise for the ice cream and friendly management. It stays open until 10 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday.
Many ice cream flavors
Late weekend hours
Pickup and delivery
“The remodel is nice, cleaner looking and seems more organized. Selena is really friendly and kind.”
Ratings and review counts shown are Google ratings, displayed with attribution.
How we ranked this list
Each ice cream shop is scored on a Bayesian-weighted rating (its rating adjusted for how many reviews it has compared with the Lake Orion category average), how recently we verified its details, and how complete its listing is. Scores and ranks are stored, so the order only changes when the underlying data changes.
Ice Cream Shops in Lake Orion, MI: common questions
Which ice cream shop in Lake Orion, MI has the most Google reviews?
Eva’s Dairy Cafe has the most reviews among these listings: 610, with a 4.6-star rating. For comparison, Dairy Queen (Treat) has 177 reviews and 3.9 stars, Cookies & Cream has 137 reviews and 4.4 stars, and Baskin-Robbins has 48 reviews and 4.3 stars.
Where can I get ice cream late in Lake Orion, MI?
Baskin-Robbins at 378 S Broadway St closes at 11 p.m. on Friday and Saturday and 10 p.m. the rest of the week. Eva’s Dairy Cafe and Dairy Queen (Treat) close at 10 p.m. daily. Cookies & Cream closes at 8 p.m. Tuesday through Sunday.
Which ice cream shop is next to a park in Lake Orion, MI?
Cookies & Cream at 20 Front St is next to Children’s Park. It welcomes children, has seating, and offers free public parking. Saturday and Sunday hours are 1–8 p.m.; Tuesday through Friday hours are 3–8 p.m.
Do I need cash for ice cream in Lake Orion, MI?
Bring cash to Eva’s Dairy Cafe, which is cash-only. Cookies & Cream, Baskin-Robbins, and Dairy Queen (Treat) accept credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
Which ice cream shops in Lake Orion, MI offer delivery or pickup?
Cookies & Cream and Baskin-Robbins both offer delivery, in-store pickup, and takeout. Eva’s Dairy Cafe offers takeout but not delivery. Dairy Queen (Treat) also offers takeout.